Matt:
Greasy, very smelly, firm pastry and a vaguely unpleasant mouth feel gets the thumbs down from me! Good meat content tho.  2/5

Tom:
Certainly not as nice as Tesco's, slight seasoning wasn't enough 3/5

Nic:
Slightly too browned not as tasty slightly more crumbly not as nice as the Tesco Lincolnshire 4/5

Glen:
Strongly odered, not as nice to look at, not as tasty as tesco, not very flakey, good amount of meat 3.5/5

Simon:
nice aroma, not a nice initial taste, but quite a nice oniony after taste  3/5

Oliver:
Well, these didn't smell too good, but tasted alright so I was happy enough 4/5